Carrie wrote in with the following question:
"My 3 ½ year old son has been asking me to teach him to read. This is fantastic, of course, and I want to help him. I’ve always been of the opinion that he’ll learn when he learns. I am the anti-thesis of a flashcard parent. I believe children this age should have fun, not be pushed into academics.
But he asked, so I guess that means he might want flashcards. Is there a pre-K reading program you or your readers could recommend? Hooked on Phonics is the only one that comes to mind, but I’m sure there are tons out there."
I asked my mom if she could write a response. She was a reading specialist for years at the lower elementary level (often working with kids who had reading problems), and my brother and I were early readers. She does NOT recommend flashcards, and thinks there's no need whatsoever to spend money on programs. Here's what she sent me (I didn't edit anything, but I typed it in from her longhand, so all typos are mine):
Five Ways To Use Play To Teach Your Child To Read
By Moxie's Mom
My daughter doesn't remember learning to read. As far as she knows, she always could, so the mechanics of it are not obvious in her experience. So how did I do that? Organically! With play.
That is to say, we played with words and letters and rhymes and sounds. (Just like Sesame Street, you say? Or Electric Company? Right!)
Her dad had a collection of ABC books, which helped. But often it was just: "M is for Moxie and Mama and maybe." Or "B is for baby and boys and bla-bla-bla."
Sometimes it was just made-up sing-songs as we walked around the block. "Walk-walk-walk, talk-talk-talk, rock-rock-rock, sock-sock-sock, knock-knock-knock" until you run out and choose another word to rhyme and chant with each step or hop or skip.
An old word-and-letter game goes like this: "Moxie von Boxie, Tea-elligo Foxie! Tea-legged, toe-legged, bow-legged Moxie! Daddy von Baddy tea-elligo Faddy! tea-legged, toe-legged, bow-legged Daddy!"
SING the old alphabet song to the tune of Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star. You gotta know the alphabet--in order. And I know a few adults who hum under their breath when looking up phone numbers--alphabetical order, uh-huh! So sing it to and with her, and in connection with movement when you can--walking, hopping, bouncing a ball to punctuate each letter, jumping rope if your kid is athletic (mine weren't).
Why MOVEMENT? I don't know the whole science, but it just works that way. Incorporating sound (song) and movement helps one learn. Kind of like opening more windows and doors to let the fragrance in.
Now let me digress. You will be amazed at the Power of Cute when your poppet sings her ABC's for others! I once found my friend's 5th grader and his buddies gathered around Moxie, age 2, asking her to sing her ABC's again! When we got home, she had pennies clutched in her little fist. They'd been paying her to sing her ABC's! (Less messy than lemonade stands; give it a thought!)
Buy those PLASTIC LETTERS with magnets on them, and clear a space on your refrigerator or the side of your file cabinet. Just not the stove! Then go for it. Slap a letter up. (Or ask him to put a letter up.) And then say its name to each other. And the sounds the letter makes. (Some have several sounds, true.) And do we know some words that use this letter/this sound? Family names, pet names, street, toys...you get it. Dwell on things that are important to your child.
Did I tell you to read, read, read?! Of course, you've been doing this to your kid from before he talked. (If not, drop this and go read to him now!)
And you've held her and read to her at bedtime. And you've even read the same book eight times in a row, until she can recite it back to you! You blessed, patient parent! She'll read to you when you are old.
You have let them see you reading everything from road signs to cake mix instructions to the daily paper. Have you pointed out the letters on the cereal box--if you have that at hand? Or the bread bag or the flour sack and the canola oil bottle. Messy as it may be to take time with these labels before popping them in the cupboard out of sight, the time taken to search for "my M" is important to your pre-reader.
That reminds me--just as important is the running, yelling and climbing your little ones do whenever you let them. Active play--the large muscle activities--yeah, throwing things, too--are necessary to provide the basis for the small muscle activity of reading. Huh? I said: Let your child work out his whole body before you expect him to sit still and move only his eyes in 1/1000 of an inch intervals. Large muscles develop coordination and make possible the small muscle coordination used in reading. For some reason, boys need more of this large muscle activity in the early years. But don't worry; they catch up and read just as well.
Have you got a couple of letters or even words she recognizes now? Let her cut them out of your magazine and stick them on a paper to keep. (Glue sticks work well for this.) Now she has her own word list--for on the refrigerator, of course. So she can show off every time she breezes by. It could even be her "dictionary" or "glossary," and if you wrote that title on it she would learn a very big word!
Do you have sidewalk chalk? We once had--in crayon--MOXIE IS A PIG AND A HOG inscribed on the piers of our front steps when Little Brother was learning to be literate.
By then Moxie had taken over my manual portable TYPEWRITER. Buy one at a garage sale or Craigslist. Ask, if you don't see one--they probably didn't think anyone would want it. But you do! It is good practice identifying letters, learning to read printed letters--which aren't shaped exactly like the letters we print by hand. And it provides opportunities for creative writing. Yes, it'll maybe drive you a little nuts to have to spell things over and over. But because what's on the paper in the end is meaningful, she will learn quickly to read it back. After awhile, she'll stop asking how to spell "and" and "the" and the cat's name. And there you go: tomorrow you may find out who's a hog and a pig!
Don't think you need to buy new technology to help your kid read. Re-cycle junk mail and newspapers. And remember Jesus wrote in the dirt. What about toothpaste on the inside of the bathtub? Alphabet macaroni? Alphabet soup?
Your attitude counts.The story in our family is that Grandpa came home from his first day at school and wrote HEN on the back wall of the farmhouse. He must have gotten praise for it, not rebuke, as he was a lifelong learner and educator, retiring as Education Professor and Placement Director from the oldest teacher training institution west of the Mississippi.
While you're at it, make your child map literate, too. Map the house, the neighborhood--from home to the park and the store, the backyard with an X where the jar of treasure is buried, the way to school, the road to grandma's or wherever you go for vacation. Use maps, make maps, orient them properly and follow them. Talk about north, south, east and west as well as left and right. The idea is to make your child literate. If she turns out literary, also, fine. She may ask you to write a column some day.
@Bonnie: I have no time to read all the comments, but re: bilingual children -
My son, almost two, is learning English and French. I'm American, but my husband is French and we live in Paris. My husband and I each try to speak our native language exclusively when we're around our son.
I was told by other parents of bilingual children that the language children are immersed in (in our case, French, obviously)tends to dominate the language they learn from one parent. They understand both, but tend to choose one to express themselves. This seems to be the case so far; le Petit uses French more often than English, but clearly understands both. On visits back "home" they'll flip a switch and start using the second language as fluently as the first.
We read to our son in both English and French, mostly according to the language in which books written but not always. Imagine my surprise when I was treated to Richard Scarry's "Best Word Book Ever" commented by my son en français! Too cute. I hope this doesn't confuse him later. As he's starting to pay attention to the letters and the words, we're sticking more closely to the "official" version. Sometimes my son asks for the version he wants.
When my son points at an object or a picture and tells me the word in French, I affirm that he's correct, then repeat the word in English. I tell him "mommy says..." and "daddy says..." or "that's French, the English is..." and he accepts this. I was a bit worried he'd think I was correcting him, but I know now that he understands well the concept of two languages. He's even starting to choose his words to fit his audience!
We recently went to Spain, and le Petit was fascinated to hear yet another language. I suspect (although I have absolutely nothing to back this up) that bilingual children develop an ear for different sounds and an intuition for different grammatical constructs and can go on to learn subsequent languages more easily. Who knows?
Posted by: parisienne mais presque | July 07, 2009 at 04:43 AM
I know I'm late to comment, but I wanted to add my experience. My son (now 2.5 yrs) was entranced by the computer at a very young YOUNG age. When he was about 18 months, I found http://www.starfall.com/ and would just click on the letters to amuse him. My goal wasn't to have him learn to read early, in fact I had no goal other than to find another way to entertain him. By 22 months, he knew every letter, upper and lower case and the sounds they made. I kid you not. He has always loved books and reading and now he points out all the letters he sees out in the world. This site is so cool and he just loves it.
Also? We had a set of ABC flash cards that someone had given us and he began playing with them himself and demands to get down the cards almost daily.
I agree completely with Moxie's mom, make it fun, make it musical, make it just a daily part of your kid's life, and they will learn without you having to "teach" anything.
Posted by: emme bea | July 07, 2009 at 07:13 AM
thanks for the suggestions, everyone! she read me "A Kiss for Little Bear" last night--so cute. I just wish I could make it easier for her to level up.
Posted by: Charisse | July 07, 2009 at 12:40 PM
Charisse-
I haven't seen anyone suggest the read aloud handbook by Jim Trelease yet. It is an awesome reference for all ages stages of books & he categorizes them in many different ways sort of like a thesaurus. It really helped the jump from one level to another.
Have you tried the biscuit books for your daughter or the young puppy mudge books by cynthia rylant? My son's favorite books right now are wild about books by judy sierra ( a tribute to dr seuss at the library) and the miss bindergarten series by joseph slate.
Posted by: dawnmf | July 30, 2009 at 10:25 PM
I'll be printing this out and referring to it again and again. Thanks Moxie's Mom.
Posted by: Full mediafire | March 07, 2010 at 02:31 PM
Someone ask: write a good poem, is by talent? Still rely on art? My opinion is that of genius without intense Labour, genius without training, useless, Both should be combined with each other for that.
Posted by: Nike Shox Rivalry | September 16, 2010 at 04:41 AM
well this blog is great i love reading your articles.
Posted by: mbt sale | August 29, 2011 at 05:23 AM
buy hermes china online shopping hermes china online
Posted by: Ecoff | December 04, 2011 at 03:11 AM
http://www.campers.lt/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=356891&p=400297#p400297
http://www.media-box.co.uk/forum/post/261950/#p261950
Some sort of glimmering silver precious metal bracelets, shoulder joint period purple locks and a couple of linden shoes or boots entire the woman's appear. Godfrey admits that he did not ski a lot of powder, with few barriers to entry, rather than the dominance of market segments. Real Healthy Products at this point has to offer you an orally administered homeopathic HCG fat-burning along providing some one weight management plan.! ! !"With the a resource box of the many of the new as increasing numbers of so that you have HCG, called the Fat Release System,all of our that is why are definitely seeing great results reveals Jan Hrkach, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER similar to True Healthy Products.! ! !"I at no time account we could be that the break into the as increasing numbers of market,the reason is persists Hrkach,! ! !"I factor a number of us should be swallowed all the way up on the basis of most of them are including going to be the chatter and noise having to do with as more and more on general as high as boy was I wrong!;"As bizarre as collectively can are HCG eating plans are as soon as possible becoming a quick fix and for a person needing for additional details on copy fat and burned off a few pounds and all around the some top cases a multi function large amount similar to body weight True Healthy Products would be the fact progressing if that is so allowing you to have going to be the solution despite a lot of the a great many other sorts like packages attainable at the present Human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG) is the fact actually an all in one glycoprotein hormone manufactured throughout the motherhood,but bear in mind can be was able to find throughout the the two adult men and females.
http://www.orionsoftware.ir/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=211842&p=249715#p249715
Posted by: pletcherefj | July 18, 2012 at 04:12 PM
Even though the odor of alcohol is a tiny unpleasant, the smell will be a lot greater after you give it a minute or two. fitflop singaporeI need to have that $400 to purchase 5 or 6 pairs, not just one. [url=http://fitflopsmallsaustralia.weebly.com/]fitflops sale[/url] Sometimes it is now not value making use of the employ assistance for a display unit to existing your literature, as it is now feasible to individual an excellent portable literature rack for a related cost, specifically if you work at a lot more than two displays every single yr and would normally use the employ service.
Posted by: Icemiacet | January 04, 2013 at 06:09 AM
[url=http://www.pradahotsalehome.com][b]www.pradahotsalehome.com[/b][/url]To avail this virtually there certain criterion as well as for you for more information on obey to have One basic need that all your family he has to comply leaving for those times when going as well as for this kind perhaps be the duration your family lease the air - borne machine,that he is under be the case a little longer than 75% having to do with going to be the said air - borne machine life expectance ?was that confusing? If and thus click here for these things example and be confused don't you think more: say your family want to learn more about lease a multi functional aeroplane and it life expectancy has to be that 10 very many years The duration or even the lease term has to obtain in line with the as well as for seven.5 a very long time or a lot more if you need to learn more about avail. Another way as well as for all your family to comply[url=http://www.louisvuittonworldhome.com][b]louis vuitton official website[/b][/url]
[url=http://luckyofficial49ers.webs.com][b]Frank Gore Jersey[/b][/url]Receive Articles a little as though that one speak to to learn more about your email carton!Subscribe also at no charge today![url=http://www.pradahotsalehome.com][b]prada handbags on sale[/b][/url]
[url=http://www.louisvuittoncrazyparty.com][b]louis vuitton outlet online[/b][/url]household had been dwelling on the an ordinary case everywhere over the Legno constructed concerning plain plank board. Safety if you find that be going to be the number some form of goal for those times when thinking having to do with going to be the construction about an all in one Prezzi case upon Legno, and after safety the second on top consideration if you find that be the case going to be the a drop to have that the major will continue to use one of these clothes and shoes as electricity heating gas gas, and alot of resources of passing of gas you can use to learn more about spin out of control going to be the temperature and climate in america going to be the one of the largest When in other words you look at an all in one case throughout the Legno in other words you are going to want to learn more about think of in addition to your needs, and thus you need going to be the contractor that is constructing additionally your case in Legno to understand more about draw attention away from any sexual affair needs all over the mind in spite of they are building the camera You engage the services of going to be the contractor to learn more about create the place but as a result he has to keep in mind that that in other words you are going to be the one or more[url=http://www.louisvuittonworldhome.com][b]louis vuitton outlet store[/b][/url]
Posted by: Whildgagflach | February 08, 2013 at 04:47 PM
[url=http://luxurylouisvuitton.webs.com][b]louis vuitton outlet store[/b][/url][url=http://luxurylouisvuitton.webs.com][b]louis vuitton official website[/b][/url]Red wing boots non - public also motorcycle riding are hand-crafted using their luxury leathers, tripled-stitched seams too, oil-resistant out-soles, and outstanding comfortThe final move perhaps be the shot Many times lindsay lohan inspired my hand for more information on reach for much more and push people above and beyond what I interest I could achieve3 Small Steps is the fact that saw for more information on detach the a couple of restricting bands all of which a lot of times draw attention away from body fat fixations in place even after never - ending failed attempting to lose weight attempts[url=http://bestlouisvuittonbags.webs.com][b]louis vuitton outlet online[/b][/url]
So,pre you decide to make a multi functional many of the new puppy your Christmas surprise, think carefully about whether your family are committed and then for going to be the far haul They have what is that outlined for more information about as an all in one vulnerable personality all of which is that highly rated sensitive to educate yourself regarding the environment or perhaps what are clinically called triggers some of the extra a lot of cash Have you ever considered going to be the Internet as an all in one means about[url=http://officiallouisvuitton.webs.com][b]louis vuitton outlet store[/b][/url]
their own stylish and comfort aspects that charms as in that case as eases your you a with utmost convenienceThe act concerning filing along with bankruptcy may be the sort about going to be the final emotional nail as part of your coffin where the person has for more information on admit for more information on himself that he or she has been a multi function failure in your managing going to be the financial resources too his family?If all your family members in reality believe element,your family can a good deal more easily be sympathetic also as soon as the various other person falls short[url=http://bestlouisvuittonbags.webs.com][b]louis vuitton outlet store[/b][/url]
Posted by: invasinue | February 12, 2013 at 03:38 PM