My other blogs

I write here, too

Click through to Amazon.com

Sign Up For My Email Newsletter

Who is Moxie?

  • Not an expert, just a mom. I help people troubleshoot their parenting problems.

    About Me

    This is my philosophy.

    Search my archives on the upper left side of the screen. If I haven't addressed your topic yet, send me an email. I get 12-15 questions a day, so yours may not go up on the site, and since I have other jobs I may not answer privately, either. Someday...

    New questions post M-F at 6 am (EST), usually, with a book review up on Friday night.

The 5-year-old's reading

Sites I Love

My other blogs

« Q&A: foods that freeze well | Main | Air travel with babies and toddlers »

Comments

HollyRhea

Egads.

We haven't faced this one yet. But really, what can you do? You definitely don't want to categorize it as dirty or equate it with touching a hot stove.

I guess like pulling the plants down (that's where we're at right now), you just distract her. I think the sling idea is a great one.

And for the record, I'm terrified that my daughter will have a UTI, and I won't know it.

julia

My daughter discovered her girl bits WAY earlier that yours - around six months or so (maybe earlier) if I recall correctly.

Now, she's usually a bathtub fiddler, so I haven't had quite the problem of being confronted with this in public.

As I see it, (assuming it isn't a UTI) you have two options: 1) try to disguise the behavior as something else until she lays off it for a while, or 2) just be cavalier about it and assume most moms will get it, "Yeah! She's gonna be one happy lady when she grows up! Heh" (or something along those lines.)

As for your own reaction to it, I would offer that you certainly don't want to discourage it. That's a fast track to therapy land, if you ask me. Plus, I really mean it when I say she's lucky to have figured out what feels good so early on. Some women NEVER figure it out. And she certainly doesn't need to be told her own body is bad. Not that you sound at all like that sort of mom.

And if you were proud of you boy for finding his bait-n-tackle, surely you can be pleased for her as well.

On the covering it up side, is it something that a well placed blankie could hide?

Good luck!

suz

This topic has come up a lot around here lately- it seems to be something people laugh off and expect with boys, but assume something is wrong when the girls do it.

My now 14mo daughter discovered hers around 6mo, too. It was her favorite toy for a few weeks, now it's a diaper change/bath time thing, and our policy is to just let her play. I can't imagine any harm in it, although the UTI thing hadn't occured to me.

The blanket idea is a good one, as is the radio. (Very clever!) Do the stroller straps/seat adjust?

Distraction is probably your best option, if there's something she finds engaging enough to work. When we need to hurry the diaper change, I give her a book to read or a hair brush or something, since her other favorite activities lately have been reading to us and brushing her hair. It takes a few tries to catch her attention sometimes, but usually it works.

Kara

Example of what not to do here. I discovered that my school desk could serve another purpose in the second grade, and my (very Catholic) mom took me to a therapist, punished me when she caught me doing it, and insisted that this was the "sin" I should use during my first confession. I'm amazed that I'm as sexually well-adjusted as I am. I don't think my younger brother was ever punished, but maybe he was just sneakier about it with my parents (I know I walked in on him at least once, but I never told).

Anyway, I think the advice here is great - nothing else really to add - I just find it so interesting that gender differences are so ingrained in us, and I commend Kelly for recognizing and resisting them in her parenting.

Carla

my Daughter who is three now, started masturbating on toys at an early age probably around 6mo. DH and I have always sort of chuckled about it and if it was in public I would distract her but not make a big deal about it. She especially did it at night in her bed, and still does, most nights I find a sippy cup strategically placed and her snoozing away.

I admit a few times I have wondered at her behavior, she has a twin brother and while he plays with his occasionly, more like a side thought, she is much more intent on "pleasuring herself" I was sort of suprised because I haven't heard too many moms of girls talk about it.

So I would probably distract her if you can when it public, but not say anything negative about it, especially as she gets older.

As my daugher is in her three's now, she never does it during the day, it is just a night thing now.

It is nice to hear of other girls doing it though, so I thought I would just tell you that my daughter has been doing it since a very young age and shows no sign of it being a "phase"..

Cat, Galloping

I just really want to see this mentioned in a customer review of that stroller on Amazon! Heh.

Lisa V

One of my daughters was very into bouncing on the arms of couches, and pillows and the like from the time she was 9 months until 18 months. It was obvious why she liked it. We often would just distract her if others were around, and it would stop. Only my closest friend picked up what was going on. By the time she was really mobile and had other things to do, it stopped.

Bert used to call her the "wank monkey." This kid would be mortified today I am sure. I will never mention it to her though.

Denise

Did anyone notice...this was a topic on "House" last night!

Moxie

HollyRhea, maybe by the time she gets one she'll just go off to Student Health and get it treated herself and you'll never know about it.

Cat, you could write the review. Actually, I dare you.

Denise, did House give the same advice I did? Of course he'd insult the parents first and then walk out in a huff without giving them any real medical information. That wacky House.

peach_linen

Hee! I thought the same thing while I was watching! I even yelled at the TV, "Moxie knows what to do!"

While House *was* his usual curmudgeonly self, he actually insulted the KID more than the mom and then, yes, gave the same advice. And then high-fived the kid and gave her a sucker.

I have to say, it was one of House's more adorable Clinic moments.

Jen (yup, another one)

Ha! What fun things we have to look forward to! However, when I described this post to Cait, she said "I don't think we have to worry about the stroller - she'd never feel anything through the cloth diapers!" So maybe Kelly should try CDing and double up the diapers! :)

The comments to this entry are closed.

Search Ask Moxie


Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    BlogAds


    Sponsor AskMoxie

    Blah blah blah

    • I'm not a doctor of any sort, or a psychologist, or a development expert, or any kind of expert at all. I'm just a mom of two kids. Nothing I say here should be construed as medical or developmental advice. Read what I say, then make your own decisions. I am not responsible for your actions. Also, I don't want to buy, sell, or process anything as a career, buy anything sold or processed, and cetera.
    Blog powered by TypePad